On 24 September 2026, the Belgian Constitutional Court held that the measures Belgium has taken, and still will need to take, following the Side-by-Side Package (“SbS”) do not affect the proceedings pending before the Court of Justice of the European Union (“CJEU”). Consequently, the Belgian UTPR case will now be handed back over to the CJEU, which will have to rule on the preliminary question(s) referred to it by the Belgian Constitutional Court.
Back in July 2024, the American Free Enterprise Chamber of Commerce ("AmFree"), a U.S. not-for-profit organisation representing the collective interests of U.S. businesses, filed a petition with the Belgian Constitutional Court.
In that petition AmFree argued that the articles 35 and 36 of the Belgian Pillar 2 legislation, i.e., the provisions introducing the UTPR for Belgian Pillar 2 purposes, violate Constitutional and EU fundamental right and should be annulled. In its interim judgment of 17 July 2025, the Belgian Constitutional Court decided, in an interim judgment, that AmFree had the “legal interest” necessary to act as a claimant in the procedure. In addition to the foregoing, the Belgian Constitutional Court referred (a) preliminary question(s) to the CJEU concerning the compatibility of the so-called Pillar 2 Directive with primary EU law (cf. Case no. C-519/25). For additional detail on that matter, please consult our Global Tax Policy Alert of 18 July 2025.
Following the publication of the SbS on 5 January 2026, and the Notice of the European Commission dated 12 January 2026, the CJEU asked the Belgian Constitutional Court in April 2026, whether the measures taken or to be taken by the Belgian authorities -in view of the SbS - affected the considerations of its interim judgment. More specifically, the CJEU asked whether AmFree still had the requisite “legal interest” to pursue the annulment proceedings it had instituted prior to the SbS.
On 24 September 2026, the Belgian Constitutional Court put forward that AmFree retained its “legal interest”, despite the (Belgian) SbS implications (to date).
The Belgian Constitutional Court based its reasoning on the following arguments:
The practical impact of the decision is limited and Belgian subsidiaries subject to Pillar 2 remain subject to Pillar 2 compliance.
The ball is now back in the court of the CJEU. The decision taken by the Belgian Constitutional Court does not end the procedures and the CJEU will now have to respond to the preliminary question as posed by the Belgian Constitutional Court in July 2025.
The decision of the Belgian Constitutional Court has a limited practical impact and Belgian subsidiaries of in-scope MNEs remain subject to Pillar 2 compliance obligations. Pending a final ruling of the CJEU on the preliminary question(s), the Belgian UTPR remains in force. The outcome of the proceedings before the CJEU could have important implications for Pillar Two globally, particularly for the operation of the UTPR as its backstop mechanism.
In this podcast, Jean-Philippe Van West discusses the Court’s decision, the implications for Belgian subsidiaries of multinational groups, the next steps before the Court of Justice of the European Union, and what businesses should do in the meantime.
For a broader discussion of recent Pillar Two and international tax developments, join our International Tax Webinar on 8 October 2026 at 16:00 CEST.
Register here: https://www.pwc.be/en/events-courses/2026/international-tax-webinar-october-2026.html
Listen here: https://www.pwc.be/en/services/tax-and-legal/tax-bites-podcast-series/episode-73-belgian-pillar-two-utpr-case.html
You can listen to the full episodes via Spotify, YouTube Music and Apple Podcasts.